I’ve been seeing this image floating around and I mentioned intending to provide alt text, which led me down a hole for a little while, including sifting through links that don’t work anymore, tweets that don’t exist anymore, twitter users who have deleted their accounts, etc… so I wanted to compile information in one place in case more of the web becomes impossible to search and archive effectively… But first, the original image:
… and now, the text (verbatim)
Eight Stages of White Settler-Colonial Denial
- “They didn’t exist” (terra nullius)
Complete denial of Indigenous presence in a given area (country, province, etc). Includes denial of Indigeneity, e.g. “Indigenous Peoples are Settlers too”.
- “If they did, they weren’t here” (terra nullius)
Denial that Indigenous People inhabit/travel/harvest/exist in a specific area. Often based on euro-centric definitions of evidence of occupation.
- “If they were, they didn’t use the land” (doctrine of discovery)
Denial that Indigenous People have a connection with the Land. Often based on euro-centric worldviews of the land as something to be owned and extracted.
- “If they did, they didn’t deserve it” (great chain of being)
Denial that Indigenous People have rights to their Lands. Often based on euro-centric value judgements of “primitive vs. civilized”, “nomadic vs. sedentary”.
- “If they did, they lost it” (right of conquest)
Denial that Indigenous People retain their rights to their Lands. Often based on colonially imposed European systems of law / “might makes right” worldviews.
- “If they didn’t, it doesn’t matter anymore” (Westphalian sovereignty)
Denial that Indigenous Rights are still binding and take precedence. Often based on false claims of supremacy of colonial legal institutions and systems.
- “If it does, we need to move on”. (liberalism)
Denial that violations of Indigenous Rights requires redress. Often based on claims redress is “disruptive/unfair/reverse racism” & false calls for “equality”.
- “If we can’t, we are you” (self-indigenization)
Denial of separateness of Indigenous Peoples and Rights. Often based on attempts to reduce Indigenous Rights to Human Rights, claim Indigeneity, etc.
CC SA 4.0 “Eight Stages of Settler Denial”. Revision I
Background
As far as I can tell, it’s often attributed to Dr. Kim TallBear, who has since deleted her Twitter account, but she fortunately also published a paper where she pointed out that she didn’t create the image and instead saw it on Twitter. She apparently saw it posted by someone who went by @pazuzumycete (now deleted), who may have created the graphic or may not have.
… and since I was working with the text a lot, I ended up putting it in a latex file. If you want that text, it’s here; it produces a PDF much like this:
If you’d like to download a ridiculously high-resolution version (~10k by 13k), you can access it here. I can’t imagine why you would want that, but there you go.